Low Soil pH: To Lime or Not to Lime

In the PNW, the average pH in the top 12 inches of soil declined from near neutral to lower than 5.7 by 1984 after years of nitrogen fertilizer applications. Soil pH further declined to lower than 5.2 by 1995, after another 10 years nitrogen fertilizer application. A soil survey conducted by Paul Carter (WSU) in 2014 found that 97% of surveyed minimum and no-till wheat fields in the Columbia County had a soil pH lower than 5.0 at 3-6 inch (seed/rooting zone) soil depths. Similar survey numbers have been observed in many areas across the eastern Washington dryland crop production areas. The soil pH will continue to decline as a result of continued nitrogen fertilizer applications if no mitigation actions are taken to reverse the acidification process. In fact, our recent survey found that many grower fields or areas of fields have pH values as low as 4.0. Some farmers in Montana have reported extremely low soil pH on their farms and those fields are no longer suitable for some crop production.

When soil pH is low, soil chemistry, fertility, and soil microbes are shifted to the direction that is unfavorable to soil and crop health. This includes reduced nutrient availability, increased incidence of plant disease, reduced herbicide, and pesticide efficacy, and reduced choices for crops and varieties you can grow. For example, Paul Carter has found increasing soil pH, through liming acidified soils, significantly increased micronutrient uptake and improved winter and spring wheat yields by 7 to 17% respectively. Dr. Tim Murry has found that increasing soil pH of the can reduce some crop disease incidences.

Liming, to counteract soil acidification, has not been a common practice in the PNW due to the lack of documented crop response to liming, economically feasible methods, and locally available low-cost liming materials. For example, traditional coarse ag lime materials are less effective for reduced tillage soils because they are slow to break down. Without tillage, it may take many years for some of these lime materials to change the acidified soil layers. More finely ground lime product applications can accelerate the rate of change, but applications of these more highly refined lime products may be less economically viable in the PNW.

Researchers at Washington State University have been conducting studies on PNW soils to improve soil and crop health and to evaluate using locally available industrial materials as alternative liming sources. The results of these projects will show you why liming is necessary and where lower cost materials might be found that have high liming values and are currently disposed of as waste. These studies may also help in understanding product and application methods for the most economically effective results in various cropping systems.

For further information, view the Soil & Water Publications page.


The WSU Farmers Network is hosting a workshop event on February 21, 2019, at 7:45 am – 3:45 pm at Banyans on the Ridge in Pullman, Washington. The workshop will present various topics of soil pH issues, soil microbial shifts under low pH conditions, soil pH effects on pathogens and how liming can reduce the occurrence of pathogens in wheat, under what circumstances you will see value of liming, herbicide persistence under low pH conditions, and local available industry co-products that can be used as liming materials.

For workshop details and registration, visit the Farmer’s Network Soil Acidity Amelioration workshop page for details. 


For workshop registration, please contact Keith Curran via email at keith.curran@wsu.edu or Carol McFarland via email at carol.mcfarland@wsu.edu, in the Department of Crop and Soil Sciences at the Washington State University.

For general questions or comments, contact Paul Carter via email at cart@wsu.edu, Associate Professor, WSU Extension and Columbia County Director; or Haiying Tao via email at haiying.tao@wsu.edu, Assistant Professor, Department of Crop and Soil Sciences at the Washington State University.

 

Washington State University